Blogs

Partridge Landscaping Ltd.

Tractor Snow Removal vs. Snow Blower: Which Is Better for Your Driveway?

snow removal in a driveway in London ontario

Tractor Snow Removal vs. Snow Blower: Which Is Better for Your Driveway?

A snow blower is usually the better choice if your driveway is short, you are home on winter mornings, and you do not mind maintaining a machine. A tractor service is usually the better choice once the driveway is long or wide, you leave early, or the pile has nowhere left to go by February. The two methods move snow differently, not just faster or slower, and that difference decides most driveways. Here is how to tell which one fits yours.

What each method actually does with the snow

This is the part that gets skipped, and it is the part that matters.

A snow blower picks snow up and throws it. The snow leaves the driveway through a chute and lands wherever the chute is aimed. Nothing accumulates at the edge of the driveway, which is why blowers keep working in late season when the banks are already high — they throw over the bank instead of pushing into it.

A tractor with a plow attachment pushes snow. It moves the full width of the driveway in a pass and stacks what it moves at the edges. It is far quicker across a large surface, and it deals easily with the heavy, dense snow that stalls a smaller machine. The limit is space: a plow needs somewhere to put the pile.

Everything else follows from those two sentences.

Snow blowers are not one thing

Blower capability varies enough that “I’ll just get a snow blower” is not a plan on its own. According to Toro’s own buying guidance, a single-stage machine clears up to about nine inches at a time and “should not be used on unpaved surfaces.” A two-stage machine is the one built for “snowfalls of 12 inches or more, big snow drifts, and hard compacted snow,” and it is the class that runs on concrete, asphalt or gravel and handles steeper slopes.

If your driveway is gravel, or if the end-of-driveway pile is your real problem, the single-stage machines that dominate the lower end of the shelf are the wrong tool. That is a common and expensive mistake.

Side-by-side comparison

Snow blower (yours) Tractor service (hired)
Who does the work You, every snowfall An assigned operator
How snow is moved Thrown clear of the driveway Pushed and stacked at the edges
Large or long driveways Slow — you walk every square foot Strong — cleared in passes
Heavy, wet, plow-packed snow Two-stage only Strong
Gravel driveways Two-stage only, with skid shoes set Depends on the contractor — ask
Late-season high banks Strong — throws over the bank Weakens as stacking space runs out
Tight spots, steps, walkways Strong Driveway only unless shovelling is added
If you leave for work at 6 a.m. You clear it first, in the dark Cleared to the contractor’s target time
If you’re away or unwell Nothing gets cleared Still gets cleared
Ongoing effort Fuel, storage, annual service, your time A phone call in the fall

The part most comparisons miss: the city windrow

Clearing your driveway once is not the job. Clearing it again after the city plow goes past is the job.

The City of London sends plows onto local streets after 10 centimetres of snow and aims to clear them within 24 hours. The City is direct about the consequence: “Due to plows pushing snow from the road to the boulevard, a plow will fill in driveways. It’s the property owner’s responsibility to maintain property access.”

That ridge across your driveway apron — the windrow — is the hardest snow you will deal with all winter. It has been compacted by a plow blade, it is often mixed with road grit, and it arrives after you have already cleared the driveway once. A homeowner with a single-stage blower will usually be out there with a shovel. A homeowner with a two-stage machine will get through it, but rarely on the first pass.

It also creates the trap that catches people every winter. Pushing that ridge back into the street is not a shortcut, it is an offence. London’s Streets By-law S-1 states at section 8.2(a) that “No person shall deposit, or cause to be deposited, snow or ice upon a sidewalk or roadway,” and at 8.3(a) that “No person shall move, or cause to be moved, snow or ice from privately-owned lands to a boulevard, sidewalk or roadway.” The City may clear it and bill the owner, with the cost recoverable through the tax roll.

So the practical question is not only how your driveway gets cleared. It is who comes back for the windrow, and where that snow is allowed to go. If you are clearing it yourself, the answer is you, onto your own property. If you are hiring, ask whether the return pass after the city plow is included in the price or billed separately. The answer varies between contractors and it is worth knowing before you sign.

(London residents who need help clearing a laneway can also ask to be matched with a volunteer through the City’s Snow Angels program.)

When a snow blower is the better choice

Straight answer, because this will be true for some readers:

  • Your driveway is a single car length and paved. A capable two-stage machine handles it in well under the time it takes a contractor to reach your street.
  • You’re home on winter mornings. Flexible schedule, no 7 a.m. departure, no one depending on the driveway being open.
  • You want walkways, steps and the back deck done too. A blower goes wherever you go. A driveway contract covers the driveway.
  • You don’t mind owning a machine. Fuel, a spot in the garage all summer, a service every fall, and the reality that small engines fail on the coldest morning of the year.
  • You genuinely don’t mind the work. Some people don’t. That is a legitimate answer.

If several of those describe you, buy the right class of machine — two-stage if you have gravel, a slope, or a windrow to fight — and skip the contract.

When a tractor service makes more sense

  • The driveway is long, wide, or doubles back. Surface area is the single biggest factor. Pushing beats throwing over distance.
  • Your morning is not negotiable. Shift work, school runs, a commute out to the 401 — the driveway has to be open by a fixed time regardless of when the snow stopped.
  • You travel in winter, or the property isn’t always occupied. A machine in the garage clears nothing while you are away.
  • Clearing snow is physically a bad idea for you. This is the most common honest reason and the least often said out loud.
  • You’re tired of the February problem. By mid-winter, self-cleared driveways tend to narrow, because the banks stop accepting snow and there is nowhere left to throw it.

What matters more than the machine

Once you have decided to hire, the equipment question mostly stops mattering. What determines whether you are happy in January is the operating model, and it is worth asking three things before you sign:

  1. What triggers a visit? A contractor who waits for a large accumulation and one who goes out at 5 cm produce very different winters. Ask for the number.
  2. Do you have to call? Automatic dispatch means the crew is routed before you are awake. Call-in service means you are competing with everyone else who just woke up.
  3. Does the crew come back after the city plow? Covered above. This is the question most homeowners forget and most regret forgetting.

Those three answers tell you more about a snow contract than any equipment list.

How Partridge clears residential driveways

Partridge Landscaping Ltd. runs residential tractors with plow attachments for driveway work on its west London, Komoka and Kilworth routes, on a seasonal contract rather than per-visit billing.

The operating details behind that:

  • Crews go out at 2 inches (5 cm) — half the City’s 10 cm threshold for plowing local streets. In practice that means the driveway is often cleared before the street is.
  • Dispatch is automatic. Customers do not call in a storm.
  • The windrow pass is included. After the city plow goes through and leaves the ridge across the apron, the operator returns to clear it. It is part of the service, not an add-on.
  • Each route has an assigned operator who runs the same properties all winter, so the person clearing your driveway in April is the person who learned its edges in November.

Walkway and step shovelling and de-icing material are available as additions to the seasonal package rather than being included in driveway service — which is exactly the gap a blower-owning homeowner covers for themselves.

Frequently asked questions

Is a snow blower cheaper than hiring a snow removal service? Over a single season, usually not, once you count the machine, fuel, storage and annual service. Over several seasons, a blower can come out ahead if it lasts and you do the work yourself. The trade is money against time and reliability on the mornings you cannot afford to be late.

Can a snow blower handle the pile the city plow leaves? A two-stage machine generally can, though often not in one pass, because plow-compacted snow is much denser than fresh snowfall. Single-stage machines struggle with it. Whatever you use, that snow cannot be put back onto the road or sidewalk under London’s Streets By-law.

Do snow removal contractors clear walkways and steps? Not always. Many residential contracts, including Partridge’s, cover the driveway as the base service and offer walkway and step shovelling as an addition. Confirm what surfaces are included before comparing two quotes, because a lower price often covers less ground.

When should I decide? Before the first storm. Seasonal contracts run on fixed route capacity, and routes are built in the fall. Equipment is also easier to buy and service in October than in the middle of a January storm.

Making the call

If the driveway is small, your mornings are flexible, and you want the walkways done too, buy a two-stage machine and handle it yourself. If the driveway is large, your mornings are not yours, or the banks beat you every February, a seasonal contract with a crew running tractors is the better answer — and the windrow question is the one to ask before you sign.

If you want a confirmed price for your property, request a free consultation and we’ll quote the driveway as it actually sits.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Scroll to Top